Best Roofing Companies Near You in Elyria, OH (2026)

58 Verified Contractors 4.9 Avg Rating 9,869 Total Reviews AI-Analyzed Reviews Free Estimates Available

Top Roofers in Elyria, OH

Filter by service:

Sort by:

M&T Roofing and Restoration

5(83 reviews)
Based in ElyriaOnline EstimatesOpen Weekends
AI Review Summary

M & T Roofing earns consistent praise for exceptional communication, professionalism, and attention to detail throughout every project phase. Customers highlight the team's expertise in navigating insurance claims, punctuality, and respectful work practices that leave homes and yards in pristine condition. The company offers transparent pricing with multiple options to fit customer needs while delivering high-quality workmanship that exceeds expectations.

"I had my roof replaced by these folks last week and it was truly outstanding. My roof had some wind damage on a discontinued shingle, and so I was able to get my roof replaced on an insurance claim. They helped me start the claim process, worked with the adjuster, and put on the new roof all within about a month. I also, had an active leak they patched while the claim was in flight, free of charge. They were prompt in communication and on-time…" — Ryan B.
114 Lindsay Ct
Licensed - Not confirmedInsured - Not confirmedYears - Not confirmedWarranty - Not confirmed

+1 440-201-4341

Coates Bros Roofing

4.9(63 reviews)
Based in Elyria
AI Review Summary

Coates Roofing consistently earns five-star reviews for their professionalism, competitive pricing, and thorough workmanship on both repairs and full installations. Customers particularly appreciate the crew's reliability and efficiency—completing projects on tight timelines, protecting homes during weather threats, and leaving job sites clean—along with their courteous, down-to-earth approach that avoids high-pressure sales tactics. The company's attention to detail extends beyond roofing itself, with customers noting quality work on gutters, ventilation, and additional features, backed by clear communication and fair estimates throughout the process.

"We had an amazing experience with Coates Bros Roofing, the estimate was fair & the people/works were so down to earth. There is nothing worse than a sales guy in your house pushing this that & the other and they did not do that to us! They also fixed our corner gutter that was creating an ice rink on our front porch, vented all 3 of our vents (kitchen, 2 bathrooms) properly out of our attic instead of into our soffits, & cut & installed our sun…" — Samantha B.
7516 W River Rd S
Licensed - Not confirmedInsured - Not confirmedYears - Not confirmedWarranty - Not confirmed

+1 440-595-4675

Bill Jackson Roofing, Inc.

4.9(55 reviews)
Based in Elyria24/7 EmergencyOnline EstimatesOpen Weekends
AI Review Summary

Bill Jackson Roofing earns consistent praise from customers for their combination of quality craftsmanship, fair pricing, and exceptional professionalism. Clients appreciate the team's thoroughness—from taking time to research optimal solutions and explain work to customers, to completing jobs efficiently without cutting corners and conducting final walk-throughs. The company is known for building lasting customer loyalty through reliable, knowledgeable service across both residential and commercial projects.

"Had full tearoff, wood replaced, new roof and new gutters and we are extremely happy with it all. The roofers were extremely hard working and job was done in 1 day. Brendan Jackson are salesmen was very helpful throughout the entire process. Going above and beyond answering questions and coming by our home. Very happy with final price , no surprises! Thank you again! Would definately recommend!" — Laura H.
7516 W Ridge Rd
Licensed - Not confirmedInsured - Not confirmedYears - Not confirmedWarranty - Not confirmed

+1 440-577-5082

Kerns Roofing and Restoration

5(359 reviews)
Open Weekends
AI Review Summary

Kerns Roofing & Restoration earns consistent praise for their exceptional customer service, particularly their skilled team's ability to navigate complex insurance claims and advocate on behalf of homeowners—often securing full coverage after previous denials. Customers highlight the professionalism and dedication of individual team members like Jordan Willson, Bryan Cooper, and Michael Nicely, who provide clear communication throughout projects and go above and beyond to ensure fair outcomes. The company delivers quality workmanship efficiently, frequently completing full roof installations in a single day, with customers noting competitive pricing and meticulous attention to detail that leaves them highly satisfied.

"5 Stars – Highly Recommend Kerns Roofing and Restoration! After storm damage left us needing a new roof, a friend referred us to Kerns Roofing and Restoration—and I’m so glad he did. From start to finish, Michael Nicely was outstanding. He handled everything with the insurance company, met the adjuster on-site, and made the entire process completely stress-free. I didn’t even have to be there so I didn’t miss work! We ended up referring Kerns…" — Bruce P.
9535 Midwest Ave Unit 106
Licensed - Not confirmedInsured - Not confirmedYears - Not confirmed✓ Warranty Offered

+1 440-271-8781

Phoenix Roofing & Solar

5(208 reviews)
Open Weekends
AI Review Summary

Phoenix Roofing earns consistent praise from customers for exceptional professionalism, efficient execution, and expert navigation of insurance claims. Clients highlight the team's ability to complete complex roofing projects—including roof replacements, rotted wood repairs, and material upgrades—in single-day timeframes while maintaining meticulous cleanup standards. The company distinguishes itself through knowledgeable advocacy with insurance companies, competitive pricing, and follow-up quality checks that ensure lasting, leak-free results.

"I was so happy with my entire experience hiring Phoenix Roofing! TJ Ryan was so easy to work with and he really went the extra mile advocating on my behalf with my insurance company. We had damage after a recent wind storm and my insurance company only wanted to cover a few tiles (which coincidentally would have cost less than my deductible). TJ sited city codes and manufacturers guidelines and never gave up, eventually getting them to understand…" — Maggie M.
14408 Detroit Ave
Licensed - Not confirmedInsured - Not confirmed✓ 10 yrs in businessWarranty - Not confirmed

+1 330-524-8323

Homestyle Home Improvements

5(192 reviews)
Online EstimatesOpen WeekendsSpanish Speaking
AI Review Summary

Customers consistently praise Hometyle Home Improvements for their exceptional professionalism, responsiveness, and expertise across roofing, siding, gutters, and home repairs. The team stands out for clear communication—including regular updates during projects—knowledgeable guidance through insurance claims and financing, and meticulous attention to detail from estimate through completion. Reviewers appreciate the crew's efficiency, cleanliness, quality craftsmanship, and welcoming service, with multiple customers choosing them over competing contractors based on their reputation and thorough support throughout the entire process.

"Brandon has been phenomenal with helping me through everything with insurance and his knowledge of how to handle everything. I was blown away with his knowledge of his craftsmanship and it shows how passionate he is about his work. I know the quality of the work will be amazing when it's done and I'm going to have a house that will function and look amazing. I chose Hometyle Home Improvements vs 3 other contractors because of the service I've…" — Breauna M.
7055 Engle Rd Ste 1-102
Licensed - Not confirmed✓ Insured✓ 24 yrs in businessWarranty - Not confirmed

+1 216-200-6265

Peak and Valley Roofing

5(183 reviews)
24/7 EmergencyOnline EstimatesOpen WeekendsWomen-Owned
AI Review Summary

Peak and Valley Roofing consistently earns praise for exceptional professionalism, quality craftsmanship, and responsive customer service. Customers highlight the team's expertise in handling complex projects—from full roof replacements to emergency leak repairs—with meticulous attention to detail and timely communication throughout. The company is particularly valued for its integrity-focused approach, prioritizing quality workmanship and customer needs over pressure sales, while also providing affordable solutions and same-day emergency response when needed.

"I had a leak that presented due to an issue with my flashing on the addition to my house. I called and left a message, within minutes I received a note from Mike advising he could make it out same day only a few hours later. I was thrilled and was happy to meet Mike right on time. Mike came and walked through the house to identify where the leak was, took a look in the attic to check, and ultimately went on the roof to diagnose the issue.…" — Jason L.
20545 Center Ridge Rd # 300
✓ Licensed✓ InsuredYears - Not confirmed✓ Warranty Offered

+1 216-777-9876

ARC Roofing & Home Improvements

5(135 reviews)
Open Weekends
AI Review Summary

ARC Roofing is a family-owned company known for exceptional responsiveness, professionalism, and thorough workmanship across roofing, gutters, and exterior repairs. Customers consistently praise the team's prompt communication, attention to detail—including protective measures for neighboring properties and meticulous cleanup—and their ability to diagnose and solve complex problems like ice damming. The company delivers fair pricing, meets promised timelines, and demonstrates genuine commitment to customer satisfaction, making them a reliable choice for homeowners seeking honest, quality service.

"I had some ice damming forming in a specific part of the roof causing water to leak in and damaging my ceiling and wall. This was a repeated problem for me. It's frustrating as my roof was just replaced 2 1/2 years ago, but the company who replaced it went M.I.A. I reached out to ARC roofing, in which George Sr., George Jr, and Jose, came out first thing in the morning and identified the problem. Despite the snow and ice on the roof, they jumped…" — Mazen A.
13210 Belden Ave
✓ Licensed✓ Insured✓ 41 yrs in businessWarranty - Not confirmed

+1 216-386-3328

Eames and Sons Roofing

5(84 reviews)
Open Weekends
AI Review Summary

Eames and Sons roofing company is recognized by customers for exceptional attention to detail, with owner Joe personally overseeing projects to ensure work meets high standards—even returning to address issues discovered after completion without additional cost. Customers consistently praise the company's responsiveness and clear communication throughout the entire process, from initial estimates to scheduling and final inspections. The firm is also noted for competitive pricing and honest estimates, delivering quality workmanship and professional service that inspires strong customer loyalty and referrals.

"My wife noticed a leak from our roof that was already pushing 30 years old, so we called out some companies to take a look and get some estimates on the work. Joe came out, took a look what was going on, and gave me an estimate that was identical in scope but half the price of another estimate we received so we opted to go with Eames and Sons. Joe was fantastic to work with and kept me up-to-date on scheduling of the entire process, from dropping…" — Chris R.
13760 Blazey Trail
Licensed - Not confirmedInsured - Not confirmedYears - Not confirmedWarranty - Not confirmed

+1 440-256-6245

West Roofing Systems, Inc.

5(81 reviews)
Online Estimates
AI Review Summary

West Roofing Systems earns consistent praise from commercial and residential clients for their professionalism, responsiveness, and quality craftsmanship across spray foam, coating, and maintenance projects. Customers highlight the team's exceptional communication—from detailed proposals and daily updates to photo documentation of progress—along with their attention to detail and respectful on-site conduct. The company's long-term durability record, competitive pricing, and transparent approach without high-pressure sales tactics have made them a trusted choice that clients readily return to for future work.

"Great experience from beginning to end! Our HOA association manages a building in which we were seeking a 15-yr warranted roof coating system applied to our ~5000ft flat roof l. Complicating the project, the privately maintained heating/cooling/generators for all residential units as well as building common equipment is co-located on the roof creating obstacles to be worked around and waterproofed. From the beginning working with Greg in…" — N/A T.
271 E Commerce Dr
Licensed - Not confirmedInsured - Not confirmed✓ 47 yrs in businessWarranty - Not confirmed

+1 440-355-9929

Elyria Roofers at a Glance

Of the 58 roofing companies serving Elyria:

3
Based in Elyria
7
List a license
13
List insurance
20
24/7 emergency service
43
Open weekends
24
Offer online estimates
8
Spanish-speaking staff

Based on what each company lists on its profile or website. Always confirm licensing and insurance directly.

FAQ: Roofers in Elyria, OH

58 roofing companies serve Elyria in our directory, with an average Google rating of 4.9 across 9,869 reviews. 7 list a license and 13 list insurance — ask any contractor for proof of both before work begins.